| Product Details
Paperback: 246 pages
Publisher: Workman Publishing
Company (July 1, 1999)
Language: English
ISBN: 0761114009
Product Dimensions: 10.2
x 7.0 x 0.7 inches
Price: $12.21
Buy it now from Amazon.com
Spotlight Reviews from Amazon.com
23 of 23 people found the
following review helpful:
Big juicy information
book for tomato lovers, August 27, 2002
Reviewer: Joanna Daneman
(Middletown, DE USA)
I confess to a passionate
love of growing tomatoes that goes back to childhood. And I have an equal
love for the taste of those sun-warm, acid-sweet juicy fruits that make
summer taste like summer. This year, finally moving to a tomato-friendly
climate for the first time in two decades, I rushed to plant an heirloom
tomato even in a container, before I could cultivate a true garden.
Heirloom tomatoes come from
seeds saved by tomato enthusiasts who have done us all the huge favor of
preserving varieties of tomatoes that taste great, look interesting (all
kinds of colors) and far better than the F1 hybrid boring red globes palmed
off by the average seed company. While F1 hybrid tomatoes are easy and
reliable and very disease-resistant, they often lack that huge tomato taste
we all remember from childhood. (These hybrid tomatoes do have their place,
however. Some of the modern hybrids will mature in a very short time, thus
are the only tomatoes you can grow in hostile climates like Germany and
New England.)
This book has all the information
I need for next year's adventure in tomato culture. It lists 100 heirloom
varieties, gives their strengths (resistance to common tomato ailments,
pleasing taste, form) and their weaknesses as well. In addition, Dr. Male
provides the history of the variety, which is interesting reading. The
pictures by photographer Frank Iannotti are not only mouthwateringly lovely,
but they accurately show a typical batch of tomatoes from a given cultivar--not
all the fruits are perfect, some have typical defects such as stitching,
weird shapes and other oddities. This gives you an accurate idea of what
to expect. I compared Dr. Male's description of Yellow Brandywine to my
experience this year. Right on every point, and her explanation of "Blossom
End Rot" (an ailment that produces soft black disgusting spots at the blossom
end of the fruit) was excellent. I found out my tomatoes were stressed
by our constant brisk winds here in Delaware, not a deficiency of calcium
in the soil or water. I know now I must plant a variety that is not prone
to this defect, because it is often breezy here.
The front section of the
book is devoted to tomato culture, and is very complete, showing staking
and trellises, saving seeds, transplanting starter plants, and more.
I rate this a big green THUMBS
UP and will be salivating all winter as I plan my next tomato garden for
2003.
19 of 19 people found the
following review helpful:
Thank you Dr. Male for
3 years of fantastic tomatoes!, April 7, 2003
Reviewer: A. Ryan "Merribelle"
(Westminster, CA USA)
This is the book for anybody
who has ever bitten into a store-bought tomato and wondered whatever happened
to rich, juicy flavor. Three years ago I was asking myself that same question
when I stumbled across Dr. Carolyn Male's 100 HEIRLOOM TOMATOES FOR THE
AMERICAN GARDEN.
Written by an avid Seed
Savers' Exchange member after she had grown more than 1,000 heirloom varieties
of tomato, this book is an introduction to open-pollinated (as opposed
to the unjustly popular hybridized) tomatoes for home gardeners. Dr. Male
manages to discuss the historical and present significance of cultivating
these heirlooms in a rational voice while yet relaying her passion for
the flavorful heritage they represent to her. The field guide has full-page
photographs of each kind with notes on their colorful origins, flavor types
and everything else you could want to know about these personal treasures.
Soon you will find yourself caught up in the mania to seek out the assortment
of seeds that will yield tomatoes with character, lore and unbeatable taste.
Although it has a truncated
field guide format and flexible cover, 100 HEIRLOOM TOMATOES also serves
as an excellent primer for general tomato culture. In the first 42 pates
you will learn about selecting the right heirloom for your purposes, germinating
and transplanting, common diseases and conditions, saving your own seeds,
etc. Dr. Male looks at various standard schools of thought thoughout this
section while presenting good arguments for her own practices.
I found this book to be one
of the more honest examinations of tomato varieties, from Dr. Male's frank
mention of both pros and cons down to the photos, which displayed typical
physiological flaws alongside more perfect examples of the fruit and foliage.
After growing and sampling for myself several of the tomatoes recommended
here, I can testify that the descriptions are spot-on while leaving some
room for differing climatic and cultural conditions. Dr. Male's degree
in microbiology and her regular gardening magazine article contributions
further reinforce her as a noted authority in this field. This is a guide
that the home gardener can have confidence in.
Recommended for any home
vegetable gardener and not a few specialty market gardeners besides.
-Andrea, aka Merribelle.
Customer Reviews
100 is not enough!,
September 12, 2005
Reviewer: R. N. (NJ)
This is a great book. I
especially love the pictures with cross-sections of each tomato so you
can see the meatiness before you buy. I also appriciate that the taste
of each one is described in detail. My only complaint is that a lot of
great tomatoes are missing from this book. I hope the next volume has about
500 varieties to truley reflect the unique color, taste and shape variations
in heirloom tomatoes.
Was this review helpful to
you? (Report this)
0 of 1 people found the following
review helpful:
Great Book, July 26,
2005
Reviewer: Kim M. Hebert
Very Colorful & Helps
You Pick The Type Of Seeds To Purchase By Giving You Good Details About
Them
2 of 2 people found the following
review helpful:
GREAT REFERENCE WITH REALISTIC
PICTURES! , July 14, 2005
Reviewer: G. Morrison (Tucson,
AZ United States)
While I was impressed with
the exhaustive (yet lively) information
provided by Dr. Carolyn
Male, perhaps MOST IMPORTANT to tomato
growers are the realistic
pictures. Instead of 100 photos of
"perfect tomatoes" - you
see the imperfections associated with
each variety: i.e. if the
tomato is prone to cracking, green
shoulders, or catfacing...
she tells you this AND provides
pictures! Two years ago,
I was kicking myself for producing oddly
shaped and sometimes ugly
heirloom tomatoes. Sure wish I had this
book back then.
If YOU plan to grow heirloom
tomatoes... BUY THIS BOOK!!!
1 of 1 people found the following
review helpful:
Excellent heirloom bestiary!,
July 3, 2005
Reviewer: Neil F. Sambol
(Roswell, GA USA)
The good:
- Excellent, yet brief, overview
of heirloom tomatoes, where they come from and how to grow them.
- Wonderful descriptions
of 100 heirloom tomatoes with pictures of foliage, ripe and unripe fruit
and a fruit sliced in half so you can see the seed / solid / juice ratio.
These pictures are particularly useful because they show the tomato as
you would see it in your garden, blemishes and all. This book is not a
marketing compaign but a reality check.
- Helpful comparisons between
similar tomatoes such as "produces well for a heart-shaped variety." These
descriptions may help the gardener choose between two or more similar varieties.
Recommendations for improvement
for any future edition:
- Include more than 100 varieties
(or follow up with a volume 2). This book is wonderful and I have read
it from cover to cover several times but it leaves me wanting more.
- About 20% of the varieties
are not available commercially. Initially, I wondered why the author would
include these varieties if a grower cannot get the seeds. I believe that
one can get the seeds from the "Seed Savers Exchange" which the author
refers to frequently in the book, but it would be easier if the author
provided a little more information about where to get the seeds. It's somewhat
disappointing to read about a tomato and get all excited and then see that
it is not available commerically.
- A significant plus would
be for the author to provide a chart of the 100 listed varieties to help
the grower compare similar tomatoes:
Perhaps organized by type
(heart-shaped, round, cherry, multi-colored, etc) this list could have
columns indicating when the tomatoes ripen, flavor characteristics, productivity,
disease resistance, etc. I find myself reading through pages of text over
and over again when I should really be looking at one or two pages.
Overall, my thanks to the
author, editor and photographer for producing an excellent book.
Price: $12.21
Buy it now from Amazon.com
Text and images are copyright
by Amazon.com, Inc and used in accordance with the guidelines of the Associates
Program of Amazon.com Inc. |